Hidden Gems for Homebuyers in Pasco and Pinellas Counties

If you’re searching for a home in Florida, you’ve probably already heard about the big-name cities like St. Petersburg and Clearwater. But tucked throughout Pasco and Pinellas Counties are some lesser-known communities that offer great value, beautiful surroundings, and all the convenience of the Gulf Coast—without the premium price. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat, proximity to the water, or easy access to everything the Tampa Bay area has to offer, there are hidden gems worth exploring.

This guide explains the following:

• Beacon Square and Holiday offer affordability near the coast

• Dunedin provides charm and walkability

• New Port Richey combines riverfront beauty and historic appeal

• Gulfport delivers artsy flair and beach-town vibes

• Safety Harbor blends waterfront living with local character

Here’s a closer look at each.

Beacon Square and Holiday Offer Affordability Near the Coast

Located in southern Pasco County, Beacon Square and Holiday are two of the most underrated areas on Florida’s Gulf Coast. These neighborhoods offer proximity to the water, low-maintenance homes, and some of the most competitive prices in the region. You’ll find mid-century single-story homes, many of which have been updated, and others ready for someone to come in and make them their own.

What makes these areas appealing is their location. You’re just minutes from beaches, marinas, and parks—but without the crowd or the coastal premiums that come with more high-profile areas. For homebuyers looking for value and potential, Beacon Square and Holiday are excellent places to start your search.

Dunedin Provides Charm and Walkability

Dunedin is one of the best-kept secrets in Pinellas County. This small waterfront city is known for its walkable downtown, unique shops, and relaxed pace of life. Many buyers are drawn to the historic homes, tree-lined streets, and proximity to the Pinellas Trail—a popular spot for biking and walking that stretches all the way to St. Petersburg.

Dunedin also offers quick access to Honeymoon Island and Clearwater Beach, making it a top pick for those who want to be near the coast but prefer a quieter atmosphere. Real estate here includes a mix of cozy cottages, bungalows, and newer townhomes, all with their own character. Prices can vary, but you’ll often find better value here than in nearby beach communities.

New Port Richey Combines Riverfront Beauty and Historic Appeal

Set along the Cotee River, New Port Richey offers a mix of natural beauty and a charming downtown district that has been revitalized in recent years. The riverfront setting makes this area feel like a true escape, while still being close to U.S. Highway 19 and other major routes for commuting.

New Port Richey has a range of housing options—from small homes near the river to larger properties tucked away in quiet neighborhoods. The architecture is diverse, with Craftsman-style homes, classic Florida ranches, and even some Mediterranean-inspired designs. It’s a great place to explore if you want water access and a walkable downtown without the higher costs you’ll find in more developed coastal cities.

Gulfport Delivers Artsy Flair and Beach-Town Vibes

Tucked just south of St. Petersburg, Gulfport is a small coastal town with a big personality. It’s known for its colorful homes, eclectic shops, and vibrant local art scene. The waterfront district features a marina, pier, and beach, all surrounded by restaurants and cafés with laid-back charm.

What sets Gulfport apart is its welcoming feel and unique identity. Homes here range from compact bungalows to newer builds with modern updates, many within walking or biking distance of the water. While prices have been climbing, Gulfport still offers better value than some of its neighbors and remains one of Pinellas County’s best-kept secrets for homebuyers who want something a little different.

Safety Harbor Blends Waterfront Living With Local Character

Located on the western edge of Tampa Bay, Safety Harbor offers bay views, a quaint downtown, and a tight-knit sense of community. The town is home to a popular waterfront park and a historic spa, along with a variety of small businesses and weekly events. Its tree-shaded streets and mix of architectural styles give it a unique charm that draws buyers who are looking for something with personality.

Safety Harbor homes range from updated cottages to custom bayfront properties, with plenty of mid-sized homes in between. While it’s less talked about than neighboring areas like Clearwater or Oldsmar, Safety Harbor holds its own in both appeal and location. It’s an ideal place to find a peaceful home near the water while staying close to everything Tampa Bay has to offer.

FAQ About Hidden Gems in Pasco and Pinellas Counties

Check out these commonly asked questions about lesser-known areas in Pasco and Pinellas Counties. If you don’t see your question here, please call our office and we’ll find you the answers you need.

Are These Areas More Affordable Than Other Parts of Tampa Bay?

In many cases, yes. These neighborhoods often offer better value for the size, location, or amenities of the homes. They’re great options for buyers looking to stretch their budget without sacrificing access or comfort.

Will These Neighborhoods Still Appreciate in Value?

Market trends suggest that many of these hidden gem areas are seeing steady growth. With more buyers seeking alternatives to high-priced areas, demand in these communities continues to rise.

Are Waterfront Homes Available in These Areas?

Yes, especially in places like Gulfport, New Port Richey, and Safety Harbor. While you may not always find a large lot or private dock, you can often get close to the water for a lower price than in more widely known waterfront towns.

Is Public Transportation Accessible in These Areas?

Public transportation options vary by location, but many of these areas have easy access to main roads and are a short drive from transit hubs. Your REALTOR® can help you assess options based on your needs.

How Do I Know Which Area Is Right for Me?

Your REALTOR will help you compare neighborhoods, look at recent sales, and consider what matters most—whether that’s walkability, water access, price point, or proximity to certain features.

Pasco and Pinellas Counties have more to offer than just the big-name cities. If you’re ready to explore areas that combine value, charm, and potential, these hidden gems might be exactly what you’re looking for.

$749,800 Active

12801 Stanwyck Circle Tampa, Florida

4 Beds 3 Baths 3,086 SqFt 0.23 Acres

$1,050,000 Active

3906 Floyd Road Tampa, Florida

5 Beds 3 Baths 3,787 SqFt 0.57 Acres

$225,000 Pending

11304 Cayman Key Avenue 2 Tampa, Florida

2 Beds 3 Baths 1,152 SqFt 0.02 Acres

$465,000 Pending

2130 W Spruce Street Tampa, Florida

3 Beds 3 Baths 1,518 SqFt 0.06 Acres

Are You Buying or Selling a Home in Tampa Bay?

You can use this website to search homes for sale in Tampa Bay and all its communities. Our site is directly connected to the Tampa Bay MLS, and we update our listings every hour. You can even use our site to create your own account and get emails as soon as a new home hits the market, price change alerts and so much more.

While you’re here, check out these listings:

• Tampa Bay homes for sale
• Condos for sale in Tampa Bay
• Waterfront homes for sale in Tampa